| 2008-2009 Overall Standings | |||
| School | Total Points | Possible Points | % Ranking |
|---|---|---|---|
| Keuka College | 84 | 108 | .7778 |
| SUNY - Institute of Technology | 59.5 | 87 | .6839 |
| SUNY - Cobleskill | 63 | 103 | .6117 |
| D'Youville College | 47 | 87 | .5402 |
| Penn State - Berks | 51.5 | 98 | .5255 |
| Penn State - Harrisburg | 51 | 98 | .5204 |
| Cazenovia College | 40 | 97 | .4124 |
| Wells College | 25 | 58 | .4310 |
| Wilson College* | 9.5 | 38 | .2500 |
* Wilson College is a women's college and does not accumulate points in the men's division.
| 2008-2009 Men's Standings | |||
|---|---|---|---|
| School | Total Points | Possible Points | % Ranking |
| SUNY - Institute of Technology | 34 | 44 | .773 |
| Keuka College | 39 | 54 | .722 |
| Penn State - Harrisburg | 28 | 49 | .571 |
| SUNY - Cobleskill | 29 | 54 | .537 |
| Penn State - Berks | 25 | 49 | .510 |
| Cazenovia College | 22 | 49 | .449 |
| Wells College | 14 | 42 | .333 |
| D'Youville College | 12 | 44 | .273 |
| 2008-2009 Women's Standings | |||
|---|---|---|---|
| School | Total Points | Possible Points | % Ranking |
| Keuka College | 45 | 54 | .833 |
| D'Youville College | 35 | 43 | .814 |
| SUNY - Cobleskill | 34 | 49 | .694 |
| SUNY - Institute of Technology | 25.5 | 43 | .593 |
| Penn State - Berks | 26.5 | 49 | .541 |
| Penn State - Harrisburg | 23 | 49 | .469 |
| Cazenovia College | 18 | 48 | .375 |
| Wells College | 13.5 | 38 | .355 |
| Wilson College | 9.5 | 38 | .250 |